Accessibility and Archives: “the lethal chamber for some types of people”

This year’s Disability History Month theme is Disability, Politics and Democracy.  In the first of a two-part blog-post Philip Milnes-Smith rounds up some of the history of Eugenics shaping public policy in the run-up to the Mental Deficiency Acts of 1913.  It includes historic language which should make us uncomfortable but is too often echoed in contemporary discourse about disabled people.

Readers may have seen Channel 4’s recent programme The Experiment and been reminded of the Nazi history of Eugenics being used to justify the imprisonment, sterilisation and euthanasia of disabled people.  Presenter (and actor) Mat Fraser reflected on the experience of visiting Hartheim Castle: “Rows upon rows of victims’ personal artefacts – combs, cups, glasses and tribute plaques from relatives – made it intensely personal… I was overwhelmed with indescribable grief, terror and sadness all at once, which distilled into anger. We came back to the UK, harrowed, and determined.” 

While the programme mentioned the British history of institutionalisation of disabled people, it is important to note that Eugenics had shaped laws here too (not just Germany).  As Adam Rutherford’s 2022 book[i] notes, many of the ideas that would constitute the new ‘science’ of “Eugenics” already existed.  Here in The Descent of Man, for example, Darwin had not just noted that “the elimination of the weak in body or mind” was being deliberately prevented, but suggested it was a mistake:

“We civilized men,… build asylums – for the imbecile, the maimed, and the sick; we institute poor-laws; and our medical men exert their utmost skill to save the life of every one to the last moment. There is reason to believe that vaccination has preserved thousands who from a weak constitution would formerly have succumbed to small-pox. Thus the weak members of civilized societies propagate their kind…; but, excepting in the case of man himself, hardly any one is so ignorant as to allow his worst animals to breed.” 

In 1883, the year Francis Galton (1822-1911, see preview image) finally coined the term, it was already being understood that its ideas would reach Parliament and end in new laws: it was not just that “those in whom chronic disease or insanity is manifest will… be recognised as unfit for marriage” but that such measures would be framed positively as ensuring “there will be no weaklings to be trodden down in the ‘struggle for existence’”.[ii]  Less than three decades later, proponents of the Mental Deficiency Act were indeed arguing that it was in the best interests of the “feeble-minded” because the status quo was “causing untold suffering to thousands…, who, because it is impossible under the existing law to train them and care for them, become inebriates, prostitutes, criminals and paupers”[iii].

In 1890, William Booth (pictured in the preview image) in his In Darkest England and the Way Out had argued as part of his advocacy for enforced “Asylums for Moral Lunatics” that vagrants ought to fall within the scope:

“It is a crime against the race to allow those who are so inveterately depraved the freedom to wander abroad, infect their fellows, prey upon Society, and to multiply their kind. Whatever else Society may do, and suffer to be done, this thing it ought not to allow, any more than it should allow the free perambulation of a mad dog... [I]f all alike failed, their ability to further curse their fellows and themselves should be stayed.

They will still remain objects worthy of infinite compassion. They should lead as human a life as is possible to those who have fallen under so terrible a judgment. They should have their own little cottages in their own little gardens, under the blue sky, and, if possible, amid the green fields... But when they have reached a certain point access to their fellow men should be forbidden. Between them and the wide world there should be reared an impassable barrier, which once passed should be recrossed no more for ever. Such a course must be wiser than allowing them to go in and out among their fellows, carrying with them the contagion of moral leprosy, and multiplying a progeny doomed before its birth to inherit the vices and diseased cravings of their unhappy parents.”[iv] 

By 1900, people had also been advocating for medical inspections in schools to establish “what is normal: and, second, to effect the separation of the mentally deficient or dull from the more intelligent.”[v]  Partly this was because such children “profit little by ordinary education” and partly because “their presence is a hindrance to other scholars”.[vi]  The word ineducable was not being employed but a cost to the taxpayer was implied in “special separate classes in order to give them a reasonable chance of becoming useful citizens”.[vii]

In 1907, Galton cautioned that so far “not enough was quantitively known to justify legislation” while promising in due course “a ‘Jehad,’ or holy war against customs and prejudices that impaired the physical and moral qualities of our race.”[viii]  But others, were spooked by what was being framed as “an alarming increase of… undesirables” [ix], given the supposedly irrefutable evidence that “stocks tainted by deaf-mutism, tuberculosis, albinism, mental degeneracy, criminality, etc., are… rather more fertile than the normal stocks”[x].  It was being argued that the sums spent on charitable donations “to those the reverse of worthy” were misplaced (these days it might have been termed suicidal empathy) and could be better used to support the breeding of the ‘normal’ and healthy instead[xi]. 

Whereas Booth had ruled out sending humans “to the slaughter-house when past their prime”, now some were openly discussing “Spartan methods” (euthanasia)[xii], and enforced segregation and sterilisation to preclude the birth of “degenerates”[xiii]. In the face of the supposedly “unnatural and increasingly rapid growth of the Feeble-minded and Insane classes”[xiv], these measures aimed at the “modification of our population” by “the elimination of the unfit”.[xv]  Back in the 1880s, people were already aware that alleviating poverty could reduce the incidence of disability[xvi].

There continued to be some pushback against the idea that heredity was more important than environment, and some people were already arguing that the vaunted statistics might not be as compelling as claimed.  According to Sir Thomas Palmer Whittaker, for example, it was, “in reality upon no genuine foundation at all”[xvii] that conclusions were being drawn and repackaged as ‘common sense’ social policy.  But, when the Mental Deficiency Act was drafted, only a small minority were critical of the vagueness of its definitions[xviii].  The eugenic moral panic meant the Bill was passed with overwhelming support across the house[xix], and the country, with one Labour MP describing those targeted as “almost like human vermin… polluting and corrupting everything they touch… with no idea of washing or cleansing themselves”[xx].  If euthanasia was never officially part of plans to cut the expense, it continued to have advocates concerned that the state spent “£93 per annum per head” on “helpless automata” and “human refuse” but “only £12 per annum per head on the normal healthy child.”[xxi]

 


[i] Rutherford, Adam (2022) Control: The dark history and troubling present of eugenics, Pages 25-39

[ii] Nantwich Guardian, 24 October 1883, Page 3

[iii] Pall Mall Gazette, 28 November 1912, Page 8

[iv] https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/475/pg475-images.html

[v] Edinburgh Evening News, 16 March 1900, Page 6

[vi] Oxford Times, 17 March 1900, Page 9

[vii] Oxford Times, 17 March 1900, Page 9

[viii] Public Opinion, 14 June 1907, Page 13

[ix] Aberdeen Press and Journal, 6 April 1908, Page 3

[x] Evening Despatch, 27 May 1908, Page 4

[xi] Morning Post, 15 October 1908, Page 3

[xii] Aberdeen Press and Journal, 6 April 1908, Page 3; Walsall Advertiser, 24 February 1912, Page 7; see also Rutherford (1922), p63

[xiii] Westminster Gazette, 26 June 1908, Page 2; Bournemouth Daily Echo, 20 October 1910, Page 2

[xiv]  Asquith papers, MS 12, folios 224-8; see Rutherford (2022) pages 78-79

[xv] Nation and The Athenaeum, 16 December 1911, Page 21

[xvi] Herzog, Dagmar The Question of Unworthy Life, Page 236

[xvii] London Daily Chronicle, 29 October 1910, Page 4; Weekly Dispatch (London), 2 June 1912, Page 8

[xviii] Weekly Dispatch (London), 2 June 1912, Page 8

[xix] Jarrett, Simon, Those they called idiots, Page 367; see also Unwin, Stephen, Beautiful Lives, 2025, Page 92

[xx] Wise, Sarah, 2024, The Undesirables, Page 75

[xxi] Wise, Sarah, 2024, The Undesirables, Page 191

Thumbnail image credit: By Bain News Service, publisher - This image is available from the United States Library of Congress's Prints and Photographs divisionunder the digital ID ggbain.05091.This tag does not indicate the copyright status of the attached work. A normal copyright tag is still required. See Commons:Licensing., Public Domain, https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/Special:Redirect/page/2705670

Next
Next

Accessibility and Archives: “to hide her face”